Creamy Potato Salad Recipe

Nothing spells summer happiness quite like a big bowl of Creamy Potato Salad Recipe, chilling in the fridge and waiting to steal the show at any gathering. This salad combines tender potatoes, crunchy celery, tangy pickles, and a velvety mayo-mustard dressing that brings everything together in complete harmony. Whether you’re firing up the grill, prepping for a potluck, or simply craving some classic comfort, this is the potato salad friends and family beg for every single time!

Ingredients You’ll Need

This is one of those recipes where every single ingredient matters. Each adds its own pop of texture, a layer of flavor, or a touch of color. Let’s take a moment to appreciate the short and sweet grocery list for this Creamy Potato Salad Recipe!

• Potatoes: Choose good boiling potatoes like Yukon Golds or Russets—they turn tender and soak up that dressing perfectly.
• Onion: Adds a little bite and sharpness to balance the creaminess.
• Celery: Chopped small for that irreplaceable fresh crunch in every bite.
• Eggs: Hard-boiled and crumbled in, they give richness and body to the salad.
• White Distilled Vinegar: A splash brings brightness and helps season the potatoes from the inside out.
• Mayonnaise: The creamy star of the show—don’t be shy, use the real stuff for classic flavor.
• Yellow Mustard: Just a spoonful adds gentle tang and color.
• Pickle Relish: Delivers a sweet-sour pop and makes the dressing irresistible.
• Salt and Pepper: Keep tasting as you go for perfectly seasoned salad.
• Spring Onions (for garnish): Sliced thin, they offer freshness and a burst of green right on top.
• Paprika (for garnish): The finishing touch—sprinkle for a hint of smokiness and that iconic red dusting.

How to Make Creamy Potato Salad Recipe

Step 1: Prep and Boil the Potatoes

Start by scrubbing, peeling, and dicing your potatoes into one-inch cubes. Even pieces ensure that every potato cooks at the same rate, giving you beautiful, fork-tender cubes. Place them in a large pot and cover with cold water—this trick helps them heat gradually, so they cook through evenly. Bring them up to a boil, then simmer for roughly 10 minutes until just tender. You want them cooked, but not falling apart when mixed, so check with a fork!

Step 2: Cool and Combine Veggies

Once the potatoes are just right, drain them and let them cool for a bit—hot potatoes can make the dressing separate or turn runny. While they cool, chop up your onion and celery into small pieces. When the potatoes are cool enough to handle, transfer them into a large mixing bowl and add the chopped veggies. Not only does this step add color and crunch, but it makes sure every forkful has something to offer.

Step 3: Prepare the Eggs

While the potatoes cook, get your eggs boiling. Once cooled and peeled, you can chop them up or—my personal favorite—push them through a cooling rack directly over the salad for perfectly even egg pieces. Eggs in a potato salad are not optional in my book; they add a satisfying richness and tie all the flavors together.

Step 4: Mix the Dressing

In a separate bowl, stir together the mayonnaise, yellow mustard, pickle relish, salt, and pepper. The mayo and mustard marry together, the relish gives a sweet vinegary kick, and it all comes together as the perfect “blanket” for your cooked ingredients. Taste and adjust the seasoning—you know your crowd better than anyone!

Step 5: Bring It All Together

Now the magic happens. Pour the creamy dressing over your potato, veggie, and egg mixture. Gently fold, not stir, to keep those potato pieces intact and get everything cloaked in that dreamy dressing. Don’t rush this—gentle patience gives you that classic look and taste everyone loves in a homemade Creamy Potato Salad Recipe.

Step 6: Garnish and Serve

Just before serving, sprinkle paprika generously over the top and shower with sliced spring onions. These garnishes aren’t just for looks—they add a fresh zing with every bite and make the whole dish pop on the table. Cover and chill until cold, or serve slightly cool according to your crowd’s preference.

How to Serve Creamy Potato Salad Recipe

Garnishes

Garnishing might be the simplest step, but it makes all the difference. A dusting of paprika lends subtle flavor and eye-catching color, while a scattering of sliced spring onions brightens each serving with freshness. You can even go a little wild with chopped parsley or dill for extra herby goodness.

Side Dishes

This Creamy Potato Salad Recipe loves company at the table. It plays beautifully next to smoky grilled burgers, tender barbecue ribs, or even a platter of crispy fried chicken. Add some roasted corn, crunchy coleslaw, or juicy watermelon slices for the ultimate picnic spread—honestly, you can’t go wrong!

Creative Ways to Present

Tired of the same old bowl? Try serving your potato salad in mason jars for an adorable picnic vibe, or hollow out a big bell pepper and stuff it with salad for a colorful, edible bowl. For cocktail parties or brunches, scoop petite servings into endive leaves or cucumber cups for a personal, bite-sized twist.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Pop any leftover Creamy Potato Salad Recipe into an airtight container and refrigerate promptly. It actually tastes even better after a few hours or overnight, as the flavors mingle and marry. Enjoy within 3–4 days for best freshness and texture—just give it a quick stir before serving again.

Freezing

Unfortunately, this isn’t one for the freezer—mayonnaise and potatoes just don’t freeze well together. Freezing changes the texture of both, leading to a watery, separated salad once thawed. The best bet is to make just what you’ll enjoy over the next few days and savor every bite while it’s at its peak.

Reheating

Potato salad is meant to be enjoyed cold or at room temperature, so skip reheating. If it’s been in the fridge, let it sit for 10 minutes to take off the chill before serving again. If the dressing thickens up, add a spoonful of mayo and stir gently to restore that luscious, creamy texture.

FAQs

Can I use a different type of potato?

Absolutely! Yukon Gold, red potatoes, or Russets all work well. Just be sure to choose a variety that boils up tender without turning mushy. Thin-skinned potatoes can even be left unpeeled if you like a more rustic look.

Is there a substitute for mayonnaise?

For a lighter twist, you can swap in Greek yogurt or a mix of yogurt and sour cream. This will give your Creamy Potato Salad Recipe a tangy edge while cutting down on calories. Still, classic mayo reigns for that old-school flavor most of us crave.

How far in advance can I make this salad?

You can easily make the Creamy Potato Salad Recipe a day before you plan to serve it. In fact, a little chill time in the fridge helps the flavors develop and blend, making it even tastier.

Can I add other vegetables or extras?

Definitely! If you want to jazz things up, toss in frozen peas, diced bell pepper, chopped pickles, or cooked bacon. There’s plenty of room to get creative and make this salad your own—just keep an eye on proportions so the potatoes remain the star.

What if my salad turns out too watery?

This can happen if the potatoes are overcooked or not cooled enough before mixing. Next time, make sure you let those potatoes steam dry and cool well before adding the dressing. You can also drain off any excess liquid and stir in a little extra mayo to bind things back together.

Final Thoughts

There’s just something magical about sharing a big bowl of Creamy Potato Salad Recipe, knowing it’s going to disappear before you know it. Every bite is a little celebration of classic flavors with a creamy twist. Give it a try next time you need a crowd-pleaser—your taste buds (and all your friends) will thank you!

Print