Old Fashioned Egg Salad Recipe

There’s something undeniably comforting about Old Fashioned Egg Salad—the kind that calls back to family picnics, sunny spring lunches, and timeless deli counters. With tender eggs, a creamy dressing, a fresh crunch of veggies, and a whisper of dill, this beloved classic delivers everything you want in a nostalgic bite. In this recipe, you’ll find that the simple, familiar ingredients come together for a flavor-packed, endlessly versatile dish you’ll turn to again and again. Whether you serve it on a sandwich, alongside crisp crackers, or straight from the bowl, Old Fashioned Egg Salad never fails to satisfy.

Ingredients You’ll Need

The beauty of this Old Fashioned Egg Salad is in its simplicity: each easy-to-find ingredient plays a starring role in creating perfect harmony between flavor, creaminess, crunch, and color. Let’s break down what you need and why it matters:

• Large eggs: The backbone of this salad, they bring rich texture and satisfying protein.
• Mayonnaise: Classic and creamy, this ties everything together and gives the salad its signature smoothness.
• Dijon mustard (optional): For a hint of sharpness and gentle heat, this is a small addition that can make a big difference.
• Fresh dill (or dried): Dill brings brightness and a pop of color—fresh is best, but dried works in a pinch.
• Celery: That satisfying, subtle crunch? Celery is your friend here.
• Red onion: Adds a bit of zip and beautiful color contrast—just be sure to finely chop for best texture.
• Salt and pepper: The essential finishing touch; season to your personal taste.
• Lemon juice (optional): A splash of citrus takes the flavors up a notch and keeps things lively.
• Bread of choice (for serving): Totally optional, but a pillowy slice of fresh bread will transform your egg salad into something extra special.

How to Make Old Fashioned Egg Salad

Step 1: Hard Boil the Eggs

Begin by gently placing your eggs in a pot and covering them fully with cold water. Put the pot on the stove and bring it to a rolling boil. When you see those first big, happy bubbles, dial the heat back to low, cover the pot, and let them cook gently for 9 to 12 minutes. Quickly moving the eggs from hot water to an ice bath is a game changer: it halts cooking instantly, making peeling a breeze and keeping your yolks a perfect sunny yellow.

Step 2: Prepare the Eggs

Once your eggs are cool to the touch, peel them carefully and pop them into a medium mixing bowl. Grab a fork and lightly mash them—aim for lots of texture. Some big pieces are key for a chunky, satisfying Old Fashioned Egg Salad, so don’t be tempted to mash them into oblivion!

Step 3: Mix in the Other Ingredients

Add the creamy mayonnaise, optional Dijon mustard, your chopped dill, crunchy celery, and the pop of color from the finely minced red onion. Season with a sprinkle of salt and black pepper, and if you want just a hint of extra brightness, squeeze in a bit of lemon juice. Mix everything gently but thoroughly so every bite is equally delicious.

Step 4: Taste and Adjust

This is where you make it your own: give your Old Fashioned Egg Salad a taste. If you want a bit more zing, add a touch more mustard or lemon juice. Need extra creaminess? A dollop more mayo never hurts! Adjust the salt and pepper until the flavors shine for you.

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy

Your Old Fashioned Egg Salad is now ready to enjoy! Spoon it generously onto sandwich bread, serve it with your favorite crackers, or enjoy it solo—the world is your egg salad oyster. Every bite is nostalgic and fresh all at once.

How to Serve Old Fashioned Egg Salad

Garnishes

For an appetizing finish, a sprinkle of extra fresh dill or chives, a shower of cracked black pepper, and even a tiny dash of smoked paprika can add eye-catching color and a gentle depth of flavor. A few thin slices of radish or microgreens are also lovely on top for a crisp, vibrant touch.

Side Dishes

This salad pairs beautifully with the classics: think potato chips, a chilled glass of iced tea, and a simple green salad. Pickles or crisp dill spears offer a tangy counterpoint that beautifully offsets the creaminess of the egg salad, while a bowl of seasonal fruit rounds out any lunch spread.

Creative Ways to Present

Old Fashioned Egg Salad isn’t just for sandwiches! Try piling it into halved avocados, spooning it over lettuce cups for a low-carb twist, or tucking it into pita pockets. Mini toast points or your favorite crackers make it a charming appetizer for casual gatherings. Sometimes, it even makes an irresistible filling for deviled eggs—egg salad inception!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

If you’ve made a big batch, store your egg salad in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Old Fashioned Egg Salad will stay fresh for up to 3 days. Be sure to give it a gentle stir before serving, as the dressing might settle a bit over time.

Freezing

While many salads freeze well, Old Fashioned Egg Salad isn’t one of them—freezing will change the texture, making the eggs rubbery and the dressing watery. It’s best to enjoy this dish freshly made or within a couple of days for best results.

Reheating

This is a chilled salad that truly shines at cool or room temperature. There’s no need to reheat; simply scoop and serve directly from the fridge for a quick snack or a classic lunch. If it’s a bit too cold for your taste, let it sit on the counter for 10-15 minutes before enjoying.

FAQs

Can I use any type of mustard in Old Fashioned Egg Salad?

Absolutely! Dijon is traditional for a subtle tang, but yellow mustard brings a nostalgic flavor, and whole grain mustard adds texture. Feel free to use what you love, or leave it out for a more classic, creamy result.

What’s the best way to peel hard boiled eggs without tearing them?

After chilling your eggs in an ice bath, gently tap them all over on your countertop to crack the shell, then peel under running water. Older eggs also tend to peel easier than the freshest ones, so consider using eggs that are a week or so old.

Is there a way to make Old Fashioned Egg Salad lighter?

You can substitute part or all of the mayonnaise with Greek yogurt for a tangier, lighter version. Light mayo is also a great option. Add plenty of fresh herbs to amp up flavor without adding calories!

Can I add other mix-ins to this recipe?

Definitely! Chopped pickles, capers, or even a touch of hot sauce are wonderful. Chopped fresh parsley or chives can be stirred in for more herbal flavor. Use this Old Fashioned Egg Salad as your base, and make it your own each time.

How far in advance can I make Old Fashioned Egg Salad for a party?

You can easily prepare the salad a day ahead. Keep it tightly covered in the fridge and give it a quick stir before serving. It’s a real crowd-pleaser for potlucks and picnics because the flavors deepen as it chills.

Final Thoughts

I hope you’ll find yourself coming back to this Old Fashioned Egg Salad as often as I do. It’s one of those classic recipes that’s always just right for any occasion, and making it at home couldn’t be easier or more rewarding. Give it a try soon—and don’t be surprised if it becomes a regular guest on your lunch table!

Print